Damage inconsistency

We had a weird thing happen last night where it appeared that the damage reported in the chat log was correct (as in, applying all the correct resistances, etc) but the damage actually applied in the combat tracker was wrong and higher (probably not applying the correct resistances etc).

I was running 5.5E and using monsters from the A5E Monstrous Menagerie. I unfortunately did not think to take any screen shots.

Moderator: I've moved this to it's own thread since this isn't a bug report pertaining to a module.

Are you running any extensions? Can you replicate in a new campaign without extensions?

Some questions that will help:
* Can you provide a screen clip of the damage roll and apply message from the chat window?
* What was the damage roll for the weapon?
* What kind of creature was being attacked? Standard or custom?
* What effects were on the attacker and defender?

Thanks,
JPG